Tuesday, 23 April 2024   

You are here: Home Books
Defending the Honour of Uthmaan Bin Affaan From Al-Hajuri and His Extremist Followers: Part 8
Posted by Abu.Iyaad, Editor in Books

  Mail To Friend    Printer Friendly Bookmark and Share

Ibn Rajab al-Hanbali stated in his Fath al-Bari (8/220-221) (arabic here):

The first adhaan for Jumu'ah is introduced, it was introduced by Uthmaan. He saw that (the adhaan) will not be heard unless he increases the mu'adhdhins so that those furthest away will be informed (of time of Jumu'ah) and hence it became a Sunnah, because it is upon the Khulafaa to look into such matters for the (benefit of) the people. And from this it is understood that this returns to the opinion of the Imaam. If he is need of it (an extra adhaan), due to the abundance of people, he can do it, and if not, then there is no need for it.

And later on page 231:

And his statement in this narration which was related by al-Bukharee here, "And so the affair became established upon that", indicates that this was when Uthmaan ordered it, it continued and it was not abandoned after that. And this shows that Alee remained upon it and did not invalidate it, for two of the rightly-guided Caliphs agreed upon its performance, may Allaah be pleased with them all.

Note: Please refer to this article to see how Yahya al-Hajuri clipped this statement of Ibn Rajab in order to defend his erroneous opinion that Uthmaan innovated into the religion (with a blameworthy innovation).

The above statement is a proof against the Hajurites in that the wisdom and reason for Uthmaan (radiyallaahu anhu) instituting the first adhaan is due to a need, and wherever that need is present the action can be followed and performed (doing a first adhaan). This is also the explanation of Imaam al-Albanee (rahimahullaah). However, the claim of the Hajurites that this situation no longer exists today cannot be used to claim that the action of Uthmaan (radiyallaahu anhu) was an innovation, since Uthmaan's action was legitimate and for a valid beneficial interest and it remains a Sunnah for all time that can be resorted to as and when the situation demands it. If for argument's sake we said there is no place on this Earth today where that situation exists (for which Uthmaan instituted the first adhaan) that would still not make the action of Uthmaan to be a blameworthy bid'ah, as is clear. So there are a number of crimes of al-Hajuri (and his followers). First al-Hajuri clipped the speech of Ibn Rajab and did not complete it. Second, when you read the full paragraph as occurs above, it is clear that Ibn Rajab says that the action became a Sunnah (al-Hajuri ommitted this) and that it is implemented when the need arises.

From this it becomes clearer and clearer that the Hajurites are upon falsehood, and to defend their falsehood they are relying upon the errant opinion of Shaykh Muqbil (rahimahullaah). Please refer also to this article on the sayings of the Scholars regarding the narration of Ibn Umar about the first adhaan of Uthmaan (radiyallaahu anhu).

Link to this article:   Show: HTML LinkFull LinkShort Link
Share or Bookmark this page: You will need to have an account with the selected service in order to post links or bookmark this page.

Subscribe via RSS or email:
Follow us through RSS or email. Click the RSS icon to subscribe to our feed.


Add a Comment
You must be registered and logged in to comment.


Latest Articles
Ahmad Nishwan Al-Maldivi - Hajurite Haddadi Extremist Turns Hardcore Takfiri Kharijite
The Adhaan of Uthmaan: Bayaan Talbees Al-Hajaawirah
Documentation of Al-Hajuri's Misguided and Erroneous View on the First Adhaan
More Connections Between Haddadi Hajurites and the Extremist Haddadis Such as Abdul-Hameed Al-Juhanee
The Evil Effects of Intoxicating Bid'ah Upon the Mind, Heart and Soul of Bigoted Hajurites
The Hajaawirah, the Extremist Haddaadis and the Terrorist Kharijites of ISIS
An Exposition of the Attempts of the Qutbiyyah, Takfiriyyah, Haddaadiyyah and Hajawirah to Ascribe Irjaa to Shaykh Rabee
Yahya Al-Haddadi: A Revilement Upon Hamza, the Chief of the Martyrs
Warning Against the Extremist Haddadi Hajurite Fanatic and Seeker of Fame: Abu Fujoor Abdul-Fatah Al-Somali Al-Kanadi
Yahya Al-Hajuri Praises the Raafidee Shi'ah Whilst Declaring Shaykhs of Sunnah to Be Enemies

 Articles on Manhaj.Com
 Books Refuting Yahya al-Hajuri's Deviations

Most Popular
Shaykh Rabee in 1432H: Yahya Al-Hajuri Is a Fool and a Vile Haddadi
The Hajaawirah, the Extremist Haddaadis and the Terrorist Kharijites of ISIS
Yahya Al-Hajuri Al-Haddadi Receives Abu Al-Hasan Al-Ma'ribi Al-Mumayyi' According to the Latter's Son
Al-Albaani, Ibn Uthaymin and Al-Fawzaan Free Uthmaan From Bid'ah and Dalaalah: A Refutation of Yahya Al-Hajuri, Musa Millington, Abu Fujoor Abd Al-Fattaah Al-Kanadi (And Other Hajurites)
Shaykh of the Hajaawirah Yahya Al-Hajuri Rejected in Makkah After Seeking an Audience With Shaykh Rabee
Yahya Al-Hajuri Praises the Raafidee Shi'ah Whilst Declaring Shaykhs of Sunnah to Be Enemies
Shaykh Rabee on Khalid Al-Gharbani 'A Lying Distorting Ikhwani Haddaadee Infiltrator' and Yahya Al-Hajuri 'A Haddadi'
Why Is Shaykh Muqbil Excused and Yahya Al-Hajuri Al-Haddadi Is Not? The Answer
More Connections Between Haddadi Hajurites and the Extremist Haddadis Such as Abdul-Hameed Al-Juhanee
Lessons From the Fall and Sacking of Dammaaj at the Hands of Yahya Al-Hajuri: Shaykh Muhammad Bin Abdul-Wahhaab Al-Wasabee

Archives (View more)
2014 • December
2014 • October
2014 • August
2014 • May
2014 • April
2014 • March
2014 • February
2013 • October
2013 • September

Key Topics
ahmad nishwanal-hajurihaddaadiyyahirjaaisiskharijitestakfiris
Copyright © 2024 . All rights reserved. RSSTagsPrivacyLegal and Terms of UseSitemap